One of the best closers of the last generation, Twins great Joe Nathan was completely robbed in his first year on the ballot. Nathan did not receive the 5% requirement to advance, despite leading all relievers with at least 300 innings in ERA, FIP, saves and WPA over a six-season stretch. Nathan's case is a great example of why many Hall voters have lost their sense of logic.
Joe Nathan Got Robbed in Hall of Fame Voting
Joe Nathan Got Robbed in Hall of Fame Voting
Joe Nathan Got Robbed in Hall of Fame Voting
One of the best closers of the last generation, Twins great Joe Nathan was completely robbed in his first year on the ballot. Nathan did not receive the 5% requirement to advance, despite leading all relievers with at least 300 innings in ERA, FIP, saves and WPA over a six-season stretch. Nathan's case is a great example of why many Hall voters have lost their sense of logic.